COMPARISON · COGNITIVE TESTING

HireValid vs Criteria Corp: a CCAT alternative for small teams

Criteria offers the established CCAT and a wide assessment suite sold through quotes; HireValid suits small teams that want published monthly prices and role bundles.

The short answer

Looking for a Criteria Corp alternative or a CCAT alternative for a small team? Criteria offers the established CCAT, a wide assessment suite and video interviewing, but does not publish prices on its plans page. HireValid publishes every price, starts at $49 a month billed monthly, has a Free plan, and tests cognitive ability alongside role-specific skills in short bundles.

HireValid and Criteria compared, checked 2026-10-02
HireValidCriteria
Contract and billingMonthly by default, cancel any time; annual billing optionalNot verified; ask provider
Entry paid priceStarter: $49 USD/month, billed monthlyNo prices published on the plans and pricing pageSource, checked 2026-10-02
Free plan or trialFree plan: 3 candidates, no credit cardA free trial is offered; trial terms are not publishedSource, checked 2026-10-02
Test library358 tests in 8 categories, plus 11 role bundlesCriteria Assess: cognitive, personality, emotional intelligence, risk and skills assessments, plus TestMakerSource, checked 2026-10-02
Between hiring roundsCancel or move to Free; jobs and results stay readableNot verified; ask provider
Integrity and AI resistanceTimed tests, randomised pools and an Integrity Score for human review; evidence on paid plans; no guaranteed detectionNon-AI proctoring in Criteria Assess; AI Proctoring is listed as an add-onSource, checked 2026-10-02
Monthly billingYes, monthly is the defaultNot verified; ask provider
Candidate experienceBrowser link with no account, practice questions first, accommodations on requestCCAT: 50 items in 15 minutes, in English (US) and English (UK), with the UCAT as a language-independent versionSource, checked 2026-10-02

HireValid may fit if...

You want to see prices before you buy, start on a free plan without a sales call and screen common small-business roles with short bundles.

Criteria may fit if...

You want the established CCAT instrument, video interviewing from the same vendor or AI proctoring, and you are happy to get a quote from sales.

Loading cost calculator

Try HireValid on your next hiring round

Start free with three candidates. No credit card and no annual contract.

Start freeSee pricingFree plan. No credit card.

Quick verdict

Choose Criteria if you specifically want the Criteria Cognitive Aptitude Test (CCAT), a long-established cognitive aptitude test, or if you want assessments, video interviewing and AI proctoring from one vendor and are comfortable buying through a sales conversation.

Choose HireValid if you are a small business that wants to see prices before buying, start on a free plan without a demo, and screen candidates on cognitive ability together with the practical skills a role needs, such as customer service judgement, Excel or typing.

The choice usually comes down to two questions: do you need the CCAT itself, and do you want published, monthly pricing? If the answer to the first is no and the second is yes, HireValid is a Criteria Corp alternative worth trying on your next hiring round.

How the two compare on contract and price

Criteria's plans and pricing page describes three plans, Criteria Assess, Criteria Interview and Criteria Hire, plus add-ons such as AI Proctoring and an AI Interview Agent. When we checked, the page did not publish prices or contract terms; it offers a free trial and a demo instead. Ask Criteria for a quote and the contract length before you compare costs, because Criteria Corp pricing depends on what you buy.

HireValid publishes every price. Starter costs $49 a month and Growth $129 a month, in US dollars, billed monthly and cancellable any time. The Free plan includes three candidates, there is nothing to pay between rounds, and candidate packs add 25 candidates for $25 in busy months. See the pricing page for what each plan includes.

Because Criteria's prices are not published, the calculator above cannot show a Criteria figure. That is not a judgement on its cost, only on what we could verify.

Test library and test types

Criteria Assess covers cognitive aptitude, personality, emotional intelligence, risk and skills assessments, and includes TestMaker for building your own tests, according to its plans page. The CCAT itself has 50 items with a 15-minute limit, and Criteria notes that very few people finish all 50. It draws on an item bank of thousands of items.

HireValid's test library is focused on small-business roles. For cognitive ability, the general cognitive ability test has 24 questions in 12 minutes across numerical, verbal and pattern reasoning, and separate verbal, numerical and abstract reasoning tests are available. These sit alongside role-specific, software, programming, language, situational judgment, personality and culture, and typing speed tests, combined into eleven role bundles.

If your hiring decision rests mainly on general aptitude, the CCAT is a well-known option. If you also need evidence of job skills, a bundle that mixes cognitive and practical tests may tell you more. As a Criteria cognitive aptitude test alternative, HireValid gives you shorter reasoning tests that sit inside a role-specific assessment rather than a single aptitude score.

Cheating and AI resistance

Criteria's plans page lists non-AI proctoring in Criteria Assess and AI Proctoring as an add-on. Its AI Proctoring page describes automatic candidate photos during the assessment, periodic captures of candidate screens and audio, and screen sampling that captures open AI tools and browser activity, with a proctoring report of flagged incidents and supporting evidence for your team to review.

HireValid takes a lighter approach that small teams can run without extra add-ons: timed questions, randomised item pools, scenario details that generic AI answers miss, and browser-event signals such as leaving the tab or pasting text. Optional camera checks run only with notice and consent. The signals feed an Integrity Score on every result.

Whichever tool you choose, treat signals as a reason to ask questions, as our integrity page explains.

Candidate experience

The CCAT is available in English (US) and English (UK), and Criteria points to the UCAT as a language-independent version. Its 15-minute limit with 50 items is designed so that few people finish, which some candidates find stressful; tell candidates in advance that this is normal.

HireValid candidates open a link with no account, see the total time and the tools allowed, check their setup and try practice questions before the scored items. Most tests take 15 minutes or less, and most role bundles take 30 to 45 minutes in total. Accommodations such as extra time are available on request. The candidate guide explains what to expect.

Reporting and scoring

Criteria's CCAT page describes custom score ranges for different positions, and the plans page lists standard ATS integrations, SSO and MFA across its plans, with premium integrations as an add-on.

HireValid ranks candidates as they finish, with a score per test, an overall result and an Integrity Score. Percentiles name the reference group they compare against where norm data exists. Every plan, Free included, has the integrity evidence, PDF reports and candidate comparison; Growth adds CSV export, five team seats and fairness reports to review selection rates across groups.

Who should choose Criteria

A Criteria Corp assessment is likely the better fit if the CCAT is a requirement, for example because your organisation has used it for years and wants comparable scores. It also suits larger teams that want assessments, video interviews, AI proctoring and development tools from one vendor, with SSO and integrations, and that already buy software through procurement.

Who should choose HireValid

HireValid suits small businesses that hire a few people a year and want to start today: published prices, a free plan, monthly billing and a pause option. It fits teams that want cognitive ability measured alongside job skills, with short role bundles, an Integrity Score for review and structured interview templates for the next step.

If you came here searching for CCAT practice as a candidate, see our candidate guide instead; this page compares tools for employers.

How to switch

  1. Check your renewal date

    Confirm your Criteria renewal date, cancellation terms and how to export your results before you change anything.

  2. List what you actually use

    Write down the tests, reports and integrations your team used in the last year, not every feature on the plan.

  3. Run the same role in both

    Build an assessment for one open role in each product and take it yourself, so you compare like with like.

  4. Confirm prices and security

    Check live prices, data handling and any security questionnaire your company needs before inviting candidates.

  5. Update notices and records

    Keep past results according to your retention policy and update the notice candidates see about how they are assessed.

Compare other assessment tools

Criteria is one of several tools worth weighing before you choose. Our comparison hub for pre-employment testing tools lists every head-to-head page with the date its facts were checked, and our guide to the best pre-employment assessment tools for small businesses groups ten tools by type, contract and entry price. Shortlist two, then run the same real role in each before you decide.

More comparisons

Frequently asked questions

What should I check before choosing between HireValid and Criteria?+

Review the features and usage limits in the plan you would actually buy, and confirm Criteria's current terms on its own site or with its sales team. HireValid's plans and limits are on the pricing page; website previews use illustrative data.

Does "Not verified" mean Criteria lacks that feature?+

No. It means the Criteria pages we checked did not state that detail on the date shown. Ask Criteria directly and review the current contract before deciding.

How much does Criteria Corp cost?+

Criteria does not publish prices on its plans and pricing page, as checked on 2026-10-02. It offers a free trial and a demo, and prices are given by quote. HireValid publishes its prices: Starter is $49 a month and Growth $129 a month, in US dollars, billed monthly.

What is a good CCAT alternative for small businesses?+

Yes. HireValid’s general cognitive ability test has 24 questions in 12 minutes covering numerical, verbal and pattern reasoning, and it can be combined with job-skill tests in a role bundle. It is a different test from the CCAT, so scores are not interchangeable.

Can I use CCAT scores and HireValid scores together?+

Not directly. They are different tests with different items, time limits and reference groups, so a score on one does not convert to the other. If you switch, run HireValid for whole hiring rounds so every candidate in a round is compared on the same test.

Does Criteria offer a free trial?+

Its plans and pricing page offers a free trial, but the trial terms were not published when we checked. HireValid has an Free plan with three candidates, every feature and no credit card, rather than a time-limited trial.

How does Criteria handle cheating compared with HireValid?+

Criteria lists non-AI proctoring in Criteria Assess and an AI Proctoring add-on that captures photos, screens and audio for review. HireValid uses timed, randomised tests and browser-event signals that feed an Integrity Score on every result. Neither approach can catch every case.

Is the CCAT harder than other aptitude tests?+

It is designed to be fast: 50 items in 15 minutes, and Criteria says very few people finish all of them. That makes raw scores look low, which is expected. HireValid’s cognitive tests use fewer items with more time per item, so compare percentiles, not raw scores.

Sources

  1. Criteria plans and pricing, checked 2026-10-02
  2. Criteria: CCAT overview, checked 2026-10-02
  3. Criteria AI Proctoring, checked 2026-10-02

Compare HireValid with Criteria on a real role

Start free, send a test link to your next applicants and see ranked results.

Start freeSee pricingFree plan. No credit card.
LESS GUESSWORK. MORE GOOD PEOPLE.

AI can polish an answer.
Hire for the ability behind it.

Explore advanced hiring assessments and integrity tools built for the AI era.

Start freeOr try a sample test No credit card. No annual commitment.