TL;DR
A candidate asks for extra time on your hiring test. Here is how a small business can invite, handle and record accommodation requests so every result stays fair and useful.
Pre-employment test accommodations are changes to how a hiring test is given, such as extra time, a screen reader or a different format, so a candidate with a disability can show the skill the job requires. The goal is to measure ability, not the impairment. Most small employers can handle requests with a short, consistent process.
If you hire without a recruiting team, an accommodation request can feel like legal territory you are not ready for. It does not have to be. This guide explains what the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) covers in general terms and who enforces it, how to invite requests before anyone starts a test, which adjustments suit skills and cognitive tests, and how to keep results comparable across candidates. It also covers a point many guides skip: how to read scores and integrity signals for an accommodated candidate, and when to call a qualified advisor.
What are pre-employment test accommodations?
A pre-employment test accommodation is any change to the testing conditions that removes a barrier caused by a disability while leaving the measured skill the same. The test still asks the same question. The accommodation changes the conditions around it, such as time, format, equipment or setting.
The distinction matters. If a role needs accurate data entry, an accommodation might give a candidate with a motor impairment more time to use adaptive input. Lowering the accuracy standard would be different, because that changes what the test measures.
Common examples of testing adjustments
- Extra time on timed sections
- Compatibility with a screen reader, screen magnifier or speech-to-text software
- Breaks between tests, or the assessment split across sessions
- Larger text, higher contrast or a different device
- An alternative format, such as a work sample or structured interview in place of one test
- A quiet setting, or permission to take the test at a different time of day
What the ADA says about employment tests, in general terms
The ADA is a federal civil rights law, passed in 1990 and broadened by the ADA Amendments Act of 2008, that prohibits disability discrimination in employment. Title I of the ADA applies to private employers with 15 or more employees and covers the whole hiring process, including tests.
Who is covered and who enforces the ADA
The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) enforces Title I of the ADA for private employers. Federal contractors also have obligations under Section 503 of the Rehabilitation Act, which the Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs (OFCCP) enforces. The EEOC publishes plain-language guidance on employment tests and selection procedures, which is a useful starting point for any employer that tests candidates.
The core testing principle
Under the ADA, an employer should give tests in a way that reflects the skills or aptitude the test claims to measure, not the candidate's impaired sensory, manual or speaking skills. The exception is when those impaired skills are exactly what the job requires and what the test is meant to measure. In practice, ask one question about every test: what skill am I trying to see, and is anything about the format getting in the way?
State and local laws
Many states and some cities have their own disability discrimination laws, and some cover employers with fewer than 15 employees. A business too small for the federal ADA may still have duties under state law. Treating every request seriously, regardless of headcount, is both the safer and the fairer default.
This section is general information, not legal advice. For a specific situation, speak with an employment attorney or a qualified HR advisor.
How to invite accommodation requests before testing
The best time to learn about a needed adjustment is before a candidate opens the test. A clear invitation removes guesswork for candidates and keeps your process consistent.
- Add one sentence to every test invitation. For example: If you need an adjustment to take this assessment because of a disability, reply to this email and we will work with you. Keep the wording identical for every candidate.
- Describe the test in advance. Tell candidates how many tests there are, roughly how long they take, whether they are timed, and what device they need. People can only ask for what they can anticipate.
- Name one contact person. Give an email address for requests that goes to someone who will not make the final hiring decision, where possible.
- Respond quickly. Acknowledge each request within a business day or two, and pause the test deadline while you talk.
- Never ask about a diagnosis in the invitation. Ask what adjustment would help, not what condition the candidate has.
If you want broader advice on instructions, timing and communication, our guide to giving candidates a better testing experience covers the parts of a candidate journey that apply to everyone.
How to handle a reasonable accommodation request from a job candidate
When a candidate asks for an accommodation, the EEOC expects the employer and the candidate to talk it through in what is often called the interactive process. For a small business, that usually means a short, respectful conversation by email or phone.
A simple interactive process
- Confirm the request in writing. Restate what the candidate asked for so nothing is misunderstood.
- Understand the barrier. Ask which part of the test causes difficulty, such as reading speed, timed sections or a mouse-only task.
- Agree on the adjustment. Most requests, like extra time or a breaks schedule, can be granted as asked. If you cannot grant the exact request, offer an effective alternative and explain why.
- Set it up before the test starts. Apply the adjustment in your testing tool and confirm it with the candidate.
- Check afterward. Ask whether the adjustment worked. That one question improves your process for the next person.
The free Job Accommodation Network, funded by the U.S. Department of Labor, offers practical ideas for specific situations and is worth bookmarking.
Documentation and confidentiality
When a disability or the need for an adjustment is not obvious, an employer can generally ask for reasonable documentation of the need. Many small employers find that simple requests, like extra time, are easier to grant without paperwork. Whatever you collect, the ADA requires medical information to stay confidential and separate from the general hiring file. Share only what an interviewer needs to know, such as the adjustment itself, never the underlying condition.
Common adjustments for skills and cognitive tests
Different test types raise different questions. The table below matches common needs with typical adjustments and the main thing to watch.
| Candidate need | Typical adjustment | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Slower reading or processing speed | Extra time on timed sections | Whether speed itself is an essential job skill |
| Blindness or low vision | Screen reader support, magnification, high contrast | Image-based or drag-and-drop questions may not work |
| Limited hand mobility | Extra time, keyboard-only navigation, speech-to-text | Typing speed tests may not fit the role measure |
| Fatigue or attention difficulties | Breaks, split sessions | Keep the same questions and total content |
| Deafness or hearing loss | Captions, written instructions | Audio or spoken interview steps need an alternative |
| Anxiety in timed settings | Extra time or a different time of day | Document consistently, as for any request |
Extra time on hiring assessments
Extra time is the most frequent request for skills and cognitive tests. A common practice in testing is time and a half or double time, but there is no single legal formula. Agree on an amount with the candidate based on the barrier described. Apply the extra time to the timed parts only, and keep the questions identical.
Cognitive ability tests deserve extra care, because many are timed and speed can affect scores. Our article on using cognitive ability tests fairly explains what these tests measure and why timing choices matter.
When speed is the skill
Sometimes speed is part of the job. A transcription role may genuinely require a certain words-per-minute rate. In that case, extra time on a typing test would change what is measured. Before refusing, ask two questions. Is the speed truly essential to the role, or just convenient? Could the candidate meet the standard another way, for example with speech-to-text software they would also use on the job? If the answer is unclear, that is a good moment to talk to an advisor rather than decide alone.
Keeping results comparable and fair
Owners often worry that an accommodation gives one candidate an edge. A well-chosen accommodation does the opposite: it removes an edge that the format gave everyone else. Comparability comes from measuring the same skill with the same content, not from identical conditions.
Record the adjustment, not the diagnosis
Keep a short log for each accommodated candidate: the date, the adjustment given and who approved it. Store it with your confidential records. A consistent log helps you treat similar requests the same way and shows that decisions followed a process.
Reading scores, percentiles and integrity signals
Here is the step many employers miss. Accommodations can change how a result looks, so interpret it with the context in mind.
- Percentiles and norms. Comparison groups are usually built from standard timing. Treat a percentile for an extended-time test as a guide, and give more weight to accuracy and sub-skill scores.
- Timing data. A candidate who had double time will naturally take longer per question. That is expected, not a concern.
- Integrity signals. Assistive technology can produce activity that looks unusual. Speech-to-text tools may register as pasted text, and screen readers or magnifiers can change focus or windows. Any integrity signal is evidence for a person to review, never proof of anything. If you also monitor for AI assistance, our guide to detecting AI cheating in online hiring tests explains how to review signals carefully.
- The final decision. Never reject anyone on a score, band or automated output alone. Combine test results with interviews and references, and let a person decide.
If you collect voluntary demographic data, checking selection rates across groups adds another layer of fairness. The four-fifths rule explained for small employers shows how that analysis works.
Making accessible online skills tests the default
The fewer barriers a test has, the fewer individual requests you need to handle. When you choose or build an assessment, check a few basics:
- Can the test be completed with a keyboard alone?
- Does it work with common screen readers and browser zoom?
- Can candidates use their own device, including a phone where the task allows?
- Can you set extra time or other adjustments for one candidate without changing the test for everyone?
- Are optional monitoring steps, like webcam checks, explained up front with the candidate's consent, and can you turn them off when they would create a barrier?
Accessible design does not replace accommodations. Some candidates will still need a personal adjustment, so keep your invitation sentence in place even when the test itself is accessible.
When to consult a qualified advisor
Most requests are simple. A few situations justify professional advice from an employment attorney or a qualified HR consultant:
- You are considering refusing a request, or offering something different from what was asked.
- The request involves an essential job skill, such as speed or physical ability.
- You believe an adjustment would cause undue hardship, meaning significant difficulty or expense.
- A candidate raises a complaint, or you receive a charge or letter from an agency.
- You are unsure whether federal, state or local law applies to your business.
Getting advice early is usually faster and cheaper than fixing a decision later.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to offer accommodations if my business has fewer than 15 employees?
The federal ADA employment provisions apply to employers with 15 or more employees. However, many state and local laws cover smaller businesses, so a company under the federal threshold may still have obligations. Offering reasonable adjustments to every candidate is good practice either way. Check with a qualified advisor about the laws in your state.
Can I ask a candidate what disability they have?
Before a job offer, the ADA generally restricts disability-related questions. You can ask what adjustment would help with the test. When the need is not obvious, an employer can generally request reasonable documentation of it. Keep any medical information confidential and separate from the hiring file, and share only the adjustment itself with interviewers.
How much extra time should I give on a hiring test?
There is no fixed legal amount. Time and a half and double time are common in testing, but the right amount depends on the barrier the candidate describes. Discuss it with the candidate, apply it only to timed sections, and record what you agreed so similar requests get similar treatment.
Does an accommodated score count the same as a standard score?
An accommodated score measures the same skill with the same questions, so treat it as valid evidence. Interpret percentiles with some care, because comparison groups are usually based on standard timing. Give extra weight to accuracy and sub-skill results, and combine the score with interviews and references before deciding.
What if a candidate asks for an accommodation after taking the test?
Listen and consider offering a retake with the adjustment. Candidates do not always know a test will create a barrier until they try it. Clear instructions about timing and format before the test reduce these cases. Treat late requests consistently and record the decision in your accommodation log.
Can I refuse an accommodation request?
An employer may decline an adjustment that would cause undue hardship or would remove an essential part of what the job requires. Even then, the employer should usually look for an effective alternative. Refusals carry legal risk, so speak with an employment attorney or qualified HR advisor before saying no.
Making accommodations part of your hiring routine
Accommodations work best as a routine rather than an exception. Invite requests in every test invitation, ask what helps instead of what the diagnosis is, and keep the measured skill constant while changing the conditions. Record adjustments confidentially, read timing data and integrity signals with the accommodation in mind, and let a person make every decision. When speed, hardship or a refusal is involved, bring in an advisor.
HireValid lets you set extra time and other accommodations for an individual candidate, while every other candidate keeps the standard settings. On the Growth plan, an adverse-impact report based on the four-fifths rule, built from a voluntary background form, adds a further fairness check. You can try HireValid free with three candidates, or compare the plans to find the one that fits your hiring.
Does a low Integrity Score reject a candidate?+
No. Integrity signals may have innocent explanations, including connection issues or accessibility needs. A person should review the evidence and speak with the candidate before deciding.
What will candidates need?+
A browser and a reliable connection. Typing, spreadsheets and code tasks are intended for desktop. If an employer enables camera checks, candidates must receive a clear notice and a route to request an alternative.
Are the scores official qualifications?+
No. These are tools for hiring decisions. English results are CEFR-aligned level estimates, not official certificates. Cognitive scores are not clinical IQ results.

